Silicon Valley Bank had 3 big vulnerabilities (2024)

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

Banking stocks were shaken by the Silicon Valley Bank meltdown. Yesterday, some smaller banks saw their stocks fall by over half. But today, the market seems to have taken a bit of a breather. And so we are going to look at the company at the center of this, now under federal investigation, Silicon Valley Bank. Darian Woods from NPR's podcast The Indicator From Planet Money joins me.

Hey there.

DARIAN WOODS, BYLINE: Hi there.

KELLY: All right, give me the "Cliff Notes" (ph) version. What do we need to know about Silicon Valley Bank?

WOODS: OK. So the company is about 40 years old. It started in the Bay Area in 1983. Its founders saw this gap. They saw that a lot of technology startups were being turned away from traditional banks. So they found this specialty. They serviced tech companies and their founders. And you have names like Roku, Etsy or Shopify. These are all companies that used SVB at some point.

KELLY: Well, all companies that I've heard of - these are household names.

WOODS: They are - and a slew of companies that hope to become household names. And so with this niche, SVP was expanding pretty steadily, both in the U.S. and overseas. But in 2020, with venture capital money just growing and growing, a lot of cheap money around the place, the bank's deposits shot up like a rocket, and that kind of actually sowed the demise last week.

KELLY: Let's stay with that for a second because I would think a lot of new money, a lot of cheap money would be a good thing for a bank.

WOODS: I mean, I would think so, too. But - and to be clear, having a lot of cash is a good thing. But you got to do something with that cash, and you want a little bit of interest. And what you do with the cash brings risk. And that brings me to Silicon Valley Bank's three big vulnerabilities.

KELLY: Three. All right. Let's do the list. What's number one?

WOODS: OK. So number one, it's what SVP did with all those new deposits. It bought bonds and similar assets that matured way out into the future. So these bonds - they go down in value when interest rates rise. And as we know, interest rates have been rising a lot over the last year.

KELLY: Yeah.

WOODS: And to be clear, a lot of other banks do this. They buy bonds. But SVP did this a lot more, and they weren't hedged.

KELLY: What does that mean?

WOODS: So hedged means they - unhedged means that they didn't - they had all their eggs in one basket. They were betting that interest rates would stay low. And there are ways that banks can pretty simply, I guess - I don't know - buy other eggs. There are investment deals that you can make to get higher interest when interest rates are higher. And some commentators are saying that SVB should have done this more.

KELLY: OK. So that's No. 1. What about - I'm hoping you're going to go here next - but the tech sector, the fact that there were all tied up with the tech sector. Is that on your list?

WOODS: Yeah. That - actually No. 2. So the second vulnerability is that the tech sector, you know, was its primary clientele. And this sector is actually really sensitive to interest rates in the same way. So when interest rates go higher, borrowing is harder. And then startups and tech companies find it harder to raise money. They get less deposits in the bank.

KELLY: And No. 3?

WOODS: OK. So the final flaw - that was panicked customers who weren't covered by normal federal deposit insurance. And this is run by the FDIC, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. All the banks pay into this. And the insurance usually covers accounts up to $250,000. But these accounts for startups were often in the millions. So in your average bank, about half of its customers' deposits are covered. But in SVB, only 10% of the value of its accounts were insured. So when a critical mass of the bank's customers felt like something was wrong on Thursday last week, they withdrew over a fifth of the bank's deposits in one day - $42 billion. And so no bank can sustain those kind of withdrawals and led to the authorities taking over the bank on Friday.

KELLY: And there you have it. NPR's Darian Woods from The Indicator podcast. Thanks.

WOODS: Thanks a lot. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Silicon Valley Bank had 3 big vulnerabilities (2024)

FAQs

Silicon Valley Bank had 3 big vulnerabilities? ›

These vulnerabilities—foundational and widespread managerial weaknesses, a highly concentrated business model, and a reliance on uninsured deposits—left Silicon Valley Bank acutely exposed to the specific combination of rising interest rates and slowing activity in the technology sector that materialized in 2022 and ...

Why was Silicon Valley Bank vulnerable? ›

One of the bank's major downfalls was its customer base, coming mostly from risky technology startups, and its large number of uninsured deposits which made the bank's vulnerabilities more prominent.

Why did the Silicon Valley Bank fail Chegg? ›

The collapse happened for multiple reasons, including a lack of diversification and a classic bank run, where many customers withdrew their deposits simultaneously due to fears of the bank's solvency. Many of SVB's depositors were startup companies.

Should I be worried about the Silicon Valley bank collapse? ›

The regulators were sending a clear signal that there was no need to panic. It's worth noting that the Silicon Valley Bank collapse wasn't caused by risky investments or fraud, but by the bank simply not anticipating the effect of locking its depositors' money into relatively low interest rate securities.

Did Silicon Valley Bank have a chief risk officer? ›

Silicon Valley Bank's risky mistakes

It didn't help that there was a hole in the bank's risk department at the exact moment when risk was flooding Silicon Valley. Regulatory filings show that Laura Izurieta left the role of chief risk officer in April 2022 and wasn't replaced by Kim Olson until December.

What can we learn from SVB collapse? ›

Three Lessons Every Business Can Learn from the Silicon Valley Bank Collapse
  • Understand your customer risk. One of the factors that may have led to the SVB collapse was that a large concentration of its customers belonged to one industry: technology. ...
  • Size matters. ...
  • Interest rates can change.
Mar 22, 2023

What are the red flags of SVB? ›

November 2022: *Interest rate risk simulation and modeling: The Fed found that SVB's interest rate risk simulations were not reliable and required improvements, noting that unreliable interest rate risk modeling impairs management's ability to make sound asset liability management decision.

What was the aftermath of SVB failure? ›

The fallout of SVB had a significant impact on the Japanese, South Korean and Hong Kong's stock markets, which fell by 2.67%, 3.91% and 2.81%, respectively, within two days of SVB fallout. Moreover, the European banking index slumped by 7%, evaporating 120 billion euros from the market.

Does Chegg still snitch? ›

Chegg's privacy policy states that they will not disclose student information to any third party, except where legally required. They ensure to strictly adhere to their privacy policy.

What would Silicon Valley Bank have done differently? ›

Still, the bank could have easily boosted its LCR without fixing the problem on its balance sheet, as I noted in the blog. If they had identified the issue early enough, they could have simply transferred assets from long-term mortgage-backed securities to long-term Treasuries to raise the bank's LCR.

Did anyone lose money in Silicon Valley Bank? ›

To be sure, SVB was allowed to fail and shareholders are projected to lose $850 million collectively. But both insured depositors — with up to $250,000 in the bank — and uninsured depositors will not lose money.

How could SVB be avoided? ›

Some banking experts believe that had there been better oversight of SVB's management of their investment portfolio, including regular analysis of their interest rate risks, this would not have happened. 2) Liquidity and Cash Management Planning. Timing was a big issue at play for SVB.

How does SVB collapse affect the economy? ›

CBS: How did the SVB collapse impact the tech industry and entrepreneurship? It added to the overall feeling that the VC market bubble had popped. While the overall downturn started in 2022, the collapse of SVB led to LP unease and lengthened the time that the VC market will take to recover.

Who is responsible for the Silicon Valley Bank collapse? ›

Debate about causes

He testified that "SVB failed because the bank's management did not effectively manage its interest rate and liquidity risk, and the bank then suffered a devastating and unexpected run by its uninsured depositors in a period of less than 24 hours".

Did the CEO of Silicon Valley Bank get fired? ›

Gregory Becker, who was fired from SVB shortly after its March failure, earned bipartisan derision on Tuesday for his explanations during testimony before the Senate Banking Committee. Though Mr. Becker repeatedly said that SVB's unwinding was unforeseeable, senators took a sharper view of his decision making.

Who is suing Silicon Valley Bank? ›

The World's Biggest Wealth Fund Is Suing Over Silicon Valley Bank's Failure. The world's largest sovereign wealth fund is going after the now-defunct Silicon Valley Bank, its management and advisers. Norges Bank, which manages Norway's oil wealth, attacked SVB in a legal filing late Tuesday.

In what ways did management fail to prevent Silicon Valley Bank failure? ›

Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) failed because of a textbook case of mismanagement by the bank. Its senior leadership failed to manage basic interest rate and liquidity risk. Its board of directors failed to oversee senior leadership and hold them accountable.

What was Silicon Valley Bank rated before failure? ›

When the financial system collapsed, investors were blindsided, and a cascade of bank runs ensued. Similarly, until its last gasp, SVB enjoyed an A rating — an “upper medium” grade, meaning it was at a low risk, overall, of failing to meet its financial obligations. And yet, fail it did.

What caused Signature Bank to fail? ›

An April 2023 FDIC report blamed Signature's failure on bank mismanagement, a lack of corporate governance, and failure to listen to and respond quickly to the FDIC's recommendations. Signature Bank's failure raised many policy questions around FDIC insurance, and bank and cryptocurrency oversight.

Why did SVB fail WSJ? ›

After all, some of SVB's most troublesome assets were low-risk U.S. Treasurys. At First Republic, a big problem was mortgages for low-risk superprime borrowers—not shaky subprime ones. And in all three cases, a problematic funding source was their deposits via core customer relationships.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6174

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-12-23

Address: 4653 O'Kon Hill, Lake Juanstad, AR 65469

Phone: +494124489301

Job: Marketing Representative

Hobby: Reading, Ice skating, Foraging, BASE jumping, Hiking, Skateboarding, Kayaking

Introduction: My name is Cheryll Lueilwitz, I am a sparkling, clean, super, lucky, joyous, outstanding, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.